Eco-Friendly Myths Debunked: What Actually Works?

There is a lot of information and tips regarding a sustainable lifestyle, but there are also some myths you might not even know about. Some are based on genuine science and impactful actions, while others are rooted in misconceptions, greenwashing, or simply a lack of understanding. Let’s cut through the noise and debunk some common eco-friendly myths, separating what truly works from what doesn’t.

Myth 1: Paper is Always Better

Paper straws, paper packaging, and more… This myth often stems from the perception that paper is biodegradable and, therefore, less harmful. However, the reality is far more nuanced. 

• Paper production requires significant resources, including forests, water, and energy. Deforestation contributes to habitat loss and climate change.
• Paper manufacturing can release harmful pollutants, especially since paper products such as straws and toilet paper tend to be bleached.
• Furthermore, paper products often end up in landfills, decomposing slowly due to the lack of oxygen and releasing methane, a potent greenhouse gas.

That said, plastic is also not a better option, especially when it comes to single-use plastic. Although scientists have found many biodegradable alternatives mixed into plastic products, recent studies reveal that even this option is, in fact, harmful.

These “green” alternatives can harbour surprising toxicity levels, potentially exceeding that of conventional plastics. Biodegradable and compostable plastics, often promoted as environmentally friendly solutions, might not be the magic bullet we hoped for.

The key is to focus on reducing overall consumption and choosing reusable alternatives whenever possible. When single-use is unavoidable, opt for recycled or sustainably sourced materials, regardless of whether they are paper or plastic. Check out our article on Daily Examples to Manage Plastic Use for more help. 

Myth 2: “Natural” Products are Always Eco-Friendly

The term “natural” is often used as a marketing buzzword, implying that a product is safe for both people and the planet. Many of these labels do not undergo any standardised testing or require proof. It’s simply a statement that is often only partially true or completely false. This marketing method is a smart way of making the product look more prestigious and marking up the price, yet it has nothing to do with a sustainable lifestyle. “Natural” doesn’t necessarily mean sustainable. For example, certain natural resources, like rare woods or minerals, may be harvested unsustainably, leading to deforestation or habitat destruction. Similarly, “natural” cleaning products may contain natural ingredients mixed with ingredients harmful to aquatic life. I often see this trend with cosmetics and cleaning products, where they highlight one natural ingredient and the rest are chemicals, pesticides, etc. 

Instead of blindly trusting labels, look for certifications from reputable organisations. Focus on products with minimal processing and packaging, and prioritise those made from recycled or renewable materials. Here is our Toxin-Free Cleaning Label Decoder to help you navigate the sea of cleaning products.

Myth 3: Recycling Solves Everything

Recycling is an important part of a sustainable lifestyle, but it’s not a silver bullet. The process requires energy and resources, and not all materials can be recycled indefinitely. Furthermore, some recycled materials are downcycled, meaning they are transformed into lower-quality products.

The most effective way to reduce waste is to focus on reducing consumption in the first place. Practice mindful consumption, avoid single-use items, and choose products with minimal packaging. When recycling is necessary, make sure to sort materials properly to maximise their recyclability. There are many tactics that can help you reduce your consumption from a simple capsule wardrobe to a more advanced minimalist lifestyle.

Myth 4: Electric Vehicles (EVs) are 100% Green

EVs are undoubtedly a step in the right direction, offering significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions compared to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles. However, the environmental impact of EVs is not zero. The production of EV batteries requires significant resources, including rare earth minerals, and the manufacturing process can be energy-intensive. Furthermore, the electricity used to charge EVs may come from fossil fuel sources, depending on the region. Finally, EV battery disposal is a complex process, and the majority of the batteries are currently not recycled but end up in landfills, where they pollute and add to the environmental footprint.

Focusing on renewable energy sources for electricity generation is the key to maximising EVs’ environmental benefits. As the grid transitions to cleaner energy, EVs’ overall impact will continue to improve. Additionally, manufacturers and researchers are increasingly focusing on sustainable battery production and recycling, which will help improve the efficiency and disposal issues. However, there is a lot of work still needed and ofcourse 

Myth 5: Small Actions Don’t Make a Difference

This myth can lead to apathy and inaction. While large-scale systemic changes are essential, individual actions collectively have a significant impact. Every time you choose to walk or bike instead of drive, reduce your meat consumption, or purchase a product with minimal packaging, you’re making a positive contribution.

Small actions can also inspire others to make changes, creating a ripple effect that amplifies their impact. Furthermore, individual actions can send a powerful message to businesses and policymakers, demonstrating a demand for sustainable products and practices. Advocate for policies that support sustainable practices, hold corporations accountable for their environmental impact, and support initiatives that promote a transition to a circular economy.

Myth 6: Greenwashing is Rare

Unfortunately, greenwashing — the practice of misleading consumers about a product’s environmental benefits—is widespread. Companies often use vague or unsubstantiated claims to capitalise on the growing demand for sustainable products.

To avoid being a victim of greenwashing, be skeptical of marketing claims and look for concrete evidence of sustainability practices. Research companies’ environmental policies and certifications and prioritise transparency and accountability.

Myth 7: Sustainable Living is Expensive

While some eco-friendly products may have a higher upfront cost, sustainable living can often save money in the long run. Reducing consumption, choosing reusable alternatives, and conserving energy and water can lead to significant cost savings.¹⁶ Furthermore, investing in durable, high-quality products can reduce the need for frequent replacements.¹⁷

Many sustainable practices, such as gardening, composting, and DIY projects, can be both cost-effective and rewarding.

Myth 8: “Going Green” is a One-Size-Fits-All Approach

Sustainable living is a journey, not a destination. There is no single “right” way to be eco-friendly. The most effective approach is to focus on making changes that are feasible and meaningful in your own life. Start with small steps, gradually incorporate new habits, and prioritise actions that have the greatest impact.

Focus on the three R’s: Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. But also add Refuse (to buy things you don’t need) and Rot (composting).

A holistic approach is needed, combining technological innovation with behavioral changes, policy reforms, and a shift towards a more sustainable consumption model.

The Importance of Critical Thinking and Informed Choices

In the face of overwhelming environmental challenges, it’s easy to grasp at any solution that promises to make a difference. However, it’s essential to approach eco-friendly claims with a critical eye and make informed choices based on sound science and evidence. By debunking myths and promoting accurate information, we can empower individuals and communities to make meaningful contributions to a sustainable future.

Remember that true sustainability goes beyond individual actions and requires a collective effort to transform our systems and behaviors. By working together, we can create a world where both people and the planet thrive.

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase something through one of these third-party sites, we may earn a small commission at NO ADDITIONAL cost to you. These commissions are a necessary source of income to cover our costs, allowing us to continue bringing relevant information to all our users. Learn more here.